Photograph courtesy of Carnival Film & Television Ltd. 2012 for Masterpiece. Speaking of nobility travelling without valets, when the Duke of Crowborough showed up at Downton without a valet in the very first episode my first thought was he left his valet behind so that Thomas would be taking care of him, and that would give them a chance to have a quiet talk about not wanting his indiscretion with Thomas to become well known. But even that uncertainty has been taken care of. Perhaps the lesson of all these stories of Edith being left and left and left again is nothing brings in misery like being entirely at the mercy of other people's decisions to stay or leave, which is where Edith's father, well-meaning though he may be, has left her. She will keep her baby and she will hide it with a farming family close to Downton, damn it! The new husband is required to take the family name in order to receive his father-in-laws title. These two do not like each other, and theyre quite public about it. Set in the early 1900s, the show gives a fairly accurate idea of life for the aristocracy at this time and the changes that the first world war brought to the United Kingdoms formerly rigid class system. Anna used to look after all the girls. Very sad, but at peace. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});
, Royal Family set to join Queen for Christmas at Sandringham. Earlier in the episode, the Crawleys closeted footman, Thomas Barrow, made a pass at Pamuk, which the diplomat rejected quite forcefullyso much so that he threatened to get Thomas fired. Upon learning Ediths secret, Rosamund travels to Downton Abbey to help her niece through her pregnancy, and suggests adoption options as the due date draws near. I hope this makes sense. 4,321, This story has been shared 4,289 times. But what if everyones assumptions about Bates are exactly right? | The deliciously mean-spirited piling on of indignities is unjust . [Watch Downton Abbey]. The second and subsequent sons are styled The Honourable William. 4,289, This story has been shared 2,664 times. 1,201, This story has been shared 1,163 times. Theres a lot to admire about Matthews mother, who regularly steps out of her comfort zone to improve the lives of the less fortunate, but shes also more than a tad condescending. 1,335, This story has been shared 1,201 times. I do enjoy watching sad-sack Molesley endure an endless string of indignities. Downton Abbey's Lady Edith finally got her happy ending in tonight's emotional last ever episode. Ill consider this tidbit an early Christmas gift. Like what you see? Im certain he will, and that they will be as pleasingly absurd as the Bandaged Stranger and the Missing Dog. If William is the youngest, would his title be The Honourable Lord William? They wrapped up Mrs. Hughes health scare lickety splitId thought that would last all season. Or it could just be a sign that Rosamund cares about her niece. So sad that she almost burned the house down by accident. Elizabeth McGovern as Lady Cora, Laura Carmichael as Lady Edith, and Dame Maggie Smith as Lady Violet. 'The Mandalorian' Season 3 Episode Guide: How Many Episodes of 'Mandalorian' Will There Be on Disney+? HM The Queen isnt making pin money by selling titles. Well, the countys name is Grantham so, obviously, the Robert is Lord of Grantham. But to be fair, Downton Abbey has never been kind to Lady Edith. That will nicely counter the thermonuclear war that Thomas and Mrs. OBrien seem to be about to wage. So Edith might not actually be able to manage it on her own. In the Season 1 finale, tragedy strikes. Edith doesn't marry until the last episode of the show, so Madge or any other housemaid dressed her. Septimus Spratt is her butler. It cleared up my confusion about the names and titles. Being American, I fear I have a rather limited understanding of the British system regarding the bestowing of titles. Top Filming Locations For the Tom Hanks Movie, Never Forget Joe Manganiellos Iconic Gas Station Strip Scene Now That Magic Mike XXL is on Netflix, Stream It Or Skip It: 'A Man Called Otto' on VOD, Starring Tom Hanks as a Stereotypical Grumpy Old Man, Chris Pine Laughs Off Rumors of Harry Styles Feud: "It Did Look Like Harry Spit on Me", How To Watch 'Magic Mike's Last Dance,' Now Available From On-Demand Retailers, Stream It Or Skip It: EO on the Criterion Channel, a Donkey's Life Interpreted as Art. The present Countess of Grantham is Our Cora, wife to Robert. Also, you only mention two daughters. Dear Shirley, Both Lord and Lady Grantham have blue eyes, but their eldest daughter, Mary, has brown eyes. It could also explain why Edith looks (and behaves) so different from her sisters. The family refer to the housekeeper and cook as Mrs and their family name regardless if they were ever married or not. Click here to subscribe to the Royal Central newsletter,
Remember, Lady Sibyls Fenian nuptials were also denied to us. According to this theory, the miscarriage kicks off a curse of deadly pregnancies: Lady Sybil dies in childbirth; Matthew Crawley dies in a car accident soon after the birth of his son; and when the maid Ethel Parks becomes pregnant with Major Bryants child, he dies, too. Maybe you'll get pregnant! Editors note: For the benefit of American readers who havent yet seen Season 3 of Downton Abbey, please do your best to avoid spoilers when commenting. She is the Countess of Grantham. But before that, like Im the case of Mary, the senior housemaid would be an acting ladys maid. Julian Fellowes's historical drama about a family of aristocrats and their many servants could never resist a good shocker, and it deployed plenty of them over the course of six seasons. I explore that reality in my book, My Sister, My Self: The Surprising Ways That Being an Older, Middle, Younger, or Twin Shaped Your Life. (Though I liked the idea of a succession of increasingly diminutive names. Edith is the only one of Lord Grantham's daughters to hold a title, Marchioness of Hexham. Stevenson: I cant seem to work up much excitement over Thomas and OBriens endless Spy vs. Spy battle. The family name is Crawley, and Matthew was the earls third cousin, and had the same surname. When Will 'Jesus Revolution' Movie Be Streaming? I couldnt read past ~ whos name is Robert Crawley~. These fan theories include secret parentage, undercover spies, and, of course, poison. The family would call them by their first name if it were known to them or perhaps nothing at all. That placed the footman in a tricky situation, but it was nothing a little poison couldn't fix, and thats exactly why some fans believe Thomas slipped something into Mr. Pamuks dinner. Privacy Policy. Inspired by soap operas and weepy 1950s melodramas, John Waters combines the conventions of that genre (soft lighting, teary organ music) with William Castle-like gimmickry for his most polished, biggest budgeted film yet. 3 throughout "The Lady's Maid's Bell", and Stengel would perhaps say she is plagued by . She's unluckier than Matthew, and he's quite deceased. The fact that Hartley doesn't seem to come to any certain conclusions is very apparent . Although it may not be obvious, Marys need to keep Edith under her thumb belies deep insecuritya profound flaw in her charactermaking her capable of splitting off any guilt in the service of coldly maintaining her fragile superiority. But alas, in a humiliating turn of events, poor Edith is left at the altar when her betrothed backs out of the deal, claiming it's for her own good due to the age gap between them . I interviewed over 400 women, teens, and girls about their sister relationships, and heard many stories of how damaging the constant day-to-day abuse can be to the recipients self-esteem. Due to the familys commitment to avoiding any unpleasantness, the only thing that could mitigate this dynamic, the intervention of the parents, does not take place. Anna was always maid to the girls, as it was her one of her numerous duties as head housemaid. Even Molesley, who could be considered the Jerry of Downton Abbeyhasstarted to win the admiration of the new lady maid, Baxter. and our So if you hear a woman addressed as Lady Roger or Lady George that is not her name or title, but the name of her husband (Thank you Dorothy Sayers, for that one). Knowing what you value will help you build the most meaningful life possible. PostedMarch 4, 2015 Let us return to when we met Edith, four seasons ago. One cannot buy a title. 1. Fellowes seems to have positioned her decision not as a bold move for feminism, but an opportunity to show once more that a womans greatest success is tied up in giving birth to a child and loving it. But theres been precious little kindness shown to Edith over the years. How dare Edith not be dazzlingly beautiful? Like with Lord Grantham, her title of Countess of Granthamis often abbreviated to Lady Grantham, the same as for all other Baronesses, Viscountesses, Countesses and Marchionesses. Charlotte Maria Livingston, Third Countess of Newburgh having inherited the title in her own right and passing it to her son, James Bartholomew Radclyffe (son of her husband the titular 5th Earl of Derwentwater.) No Mr/Mrs or Miss. Then, she found a sympathetic editor who soon became her lover. Good point, Ive highlighted your comment so everyone can see . Robert and Cora were devastated over the loss of their youngest daughter. I have a question: under what circumstances is it correct to address someone with the title Lord/Lady and his/her first name? Thomas: Lets make that three wedding receptions we were swizzed out of. I guess she may not technically be a Lady's Maid but a "maid who does buttons and hooks". Or at least, thats the official story. He hoped if her family got to know him, it would be easier for them to be on his side. Also, at what age do they stop calling George Master George and start calling him Mister? I like to imagine her steadily ascending the class ladder until she reappears in Season 9 as the barrister handling Mr. Bates seventh appeal trial. Meet Emily Swallow, Stream It or Skip It: 'The Mandalorian' Season 3 on Disney+, Where Pedro Pascal Is Still Daddy (But in a Helmet), 'The Last of Us Part I' Sale: Take 29% Off The Game That Inspired The Show, 'The Last of Us' Episode 7 Recap: Mallrats, Yes, Ellie Has Always Been Gay in 'The Last of Us', Who Plays Riley in 'The Last of Us'? Carson: "We may have to have a maid in the dining room." The Earl of Grantham: "Cheer up, Carson. A peer may be addressed as My Lord or Your Lordship or Sir. Why was Lady Edith jilted at the altar? How dare Edith exist for something other than marriage? My own belief is that the Crawleys would still be there.. But say Princess Di and everyone knows who youre talking about. Reviewed by Ekua Hagan. It is oddly her grandmother, the Dowager Countess, who seems to understand most fully that Edith's options are limited, and that this is not to be taken as a happy thing, only one the D.C. would argue cannot be changed. Marys happiness seems to be the only thing that matters in this household. But isnt it wild to think of Carson and Cora having an affair? She will never hold the title of Countess of Grantham, so what would her title be? (This is all leaving aside the fact that Edith's ideas about adoption seem odd, in that an adoptive family, of course, brings its own blessings, meaning the child's life is not simply devoid of joy because she cannot inherit from her birth father.). I, toosomewhat uncharitably, I realizecracked up when the ceremony only got as far as Dearly beloved, we are gathered. (This is the second consecutive Downton reception weve been cheated out of. 1,592, This story has been shared 1,546 times. And when she actually met someone who liked her, he was driven off by Mary, who was angry at Edith for revealing that Mary's romantic activities were so amazing that they killed a Turkish guy. After all, thats the triumph of Sybils storyline. One thing thats key to the show yet is not widely understood by many are the titles used by members of the family. Lady Mary Crawley (played by Michelle Dockery) has been the resident mean girl on "Downton Abbey" ever since it premiered in 2011 (via IMDb ). So the divorced Margaret had to settle for being styled Margaret, Duchess of Argyll. Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. Why doesn't Lady Edith have a lady's maid? One of the soapiest subplots of Downton Abbey's first season involved poor Mr. Pamuk, the dashing Turkish diplomat who makes a fateful visit to the Abbey. If Matthew had become Earl, what would Isobel, his mother, be? Dashing away with a soothing iron, indeed. 2,664, This story has been shared 2,161 times. The kitchen maids wondered why she was so tired looking, she was reminded of her missing/presumed dead lover, she had to pretend to not care about her secret bastard daughter (whose name is Marigold for some reason), and she almost burned down the entire house after she drunkenly threw a book into the fire. Such a tile does not make the person is a Lord nor would he be styled as such. 11,875, This story has been shared 6,465 times. OK, so if Robert Crawley, Seventh Earl of Grantham, had a son he would the the Viscount Downton. Or did he give up Lord Downtown to become Lord Gratham when his father died? This sub-plot mirrors the truth about what goes on in so many families, where often an older sister is ruthless in her need to keep her rivals head underwater so she can shine. Maybe Edith will finally get her happy ending. Brush up on the best of them before the Downton Abbey movie hits theatersjust in case the whole miscarriage curse comes up. Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company. Diana, Princess of Wales was the daughter of an Earl so, prior to her marriage, was addressed as Lady Diana Spencer. is never taken to task for the comments she makes putting her little sister down. So Edith was alone again, naturally. And yet, when Fellowes was interviewed about Edith, he claims that nothing could be further from the truth. When Violet dies, custom dictates Cora then becomes known as the Dowager Countess of Grantham. With rapier wit, effortless beauty, and keen social. "Downton Abbey's" serial mistreatment of Edith Crawley, the ultimate middle child, is one of its most telling quirks. I think Edith was right when she said that she and Anthony Strallan would be so terribly, terribly happy, but a campaign of undermining by the rest of her family pushed him to abandon her at the altar. But because Edith is Edith, he dumped her at the altar in front of her horrified family, humiliating her in front of the very people who already felt sorry for her and considered her a lost cause who would be better off as the spinster they expected her to become than as the wife of this older disabled veteran (and shame on them, by the way). In order to divorce his wife, he went off to Germany (as you do in the years following World War I, if you have a taste for adventure), where he disappeared. Three generations easily distinguished. I also feel bad for Lady Edith, who saw the one time things in that house were finally about her go terribly, terribly wrong, but Sir Anthony is a putz. Also, one senses that perhaps Edith, who kept her daughter for a few months for the sake of the breastfeeding and therefore had likely formed a fairly fully developed bond with her, would rather she weren't quite so far away, and perhaps were even somewhere that Edith might occasionally see her. You see, Edith may not be lucky, but she is not stupid, and she had come to understand that when one disappears into post-WWI Germany after being last seen with some disagreeable fellows in brown shirts, one may never be seen again. Denker and Spratts unprofessional squabbles wouldve gotten plenty of other servants fired, but fans believe the Dowager Countess keeps them employed for her own amusement. - Billy Joel - The Longest Time (Official Video) And then they rolled up the rugs on Ediths before it even began.). I would like an explanation of the names used for the servants both at Downton and in Scotland. There can be an unlimited number of dowagers. Fans Fuming Over Mayim Bialik and Ken Jennings' Hosting Schedules: "I Want Ken Full-Time". Thomas is the footman. The lower ranking staff usually have minimum contact with the family on a regular basis and are often supposed to keep out of the familys eyesight. So, go peddle your coarse garbage elsewhere! I understand that they are called Lord and Lady Grantham, I just dont understand why they go by Violets last name. Robert open your eyes! Mary will only gain a title if she marries a person with a title. But because there is such a narrow idea in her family of what constitutes success, her writing career has never been more than tepidly received, and certainly is understood to be a poor substitute for multiple pregnancies when it comes to getting some meaning in her life. Netflix's 'Money Shot' Documentary Trailer Shines A Harsh Light On Pornhub, The "Most Trafficked Website In The World", 'The Skinny Shot' on Hulu Is An Ozempic "Documentary" That Plays More Like A Commercial, Where Is Estonia Located? She is just a plain miss. The title may only be passed to an heir apparent, thus a son of the current Earl, as it is always possible for heir apparent to be born to the earl even up to 9 months after his death the heir presumptive would never be given the title. Seth Stevenson: June, you are right that Lady Mary is approaching insufferable queen bee territory. 2,161, This story has been shared 1,804 times. Never until they're married? I dont know any of this for certain but this is what I believe to be the case. Mr. Carson is Lady Mary's father. This theory all comes down to . Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Peers typically use their title as a surname when they need one though legally their surname would remain as their family name. To have to leave a child she loved with complete strangers could not have been easy. In which case, they would be identified by their order. It is nonsense to even ponder an impossibility. Considering all this, it should come as no surprise that fans have developed similarly wacky theories about the show. It's obviously less for fear of betraying military secrets to the enemy than to keep its soldiers from becoming quite inappropriate in their letters. Apologies for posting to such an old thread, but thought I might help other confused Americans find your comment when googling, since the show is still well-known even though its finished airing. Laura Carmichael as Lady Edith, whose rather appalling luck seems destined to follow her. Its a sad moment, but its also, Reddit claims, the source of the houses future misfortune. But on the other, there is this: In becoming a mother, Edith got out from under the thumb of her father. Where does Grantham come from? The family of a Lord of the Manor have no courtesy titles, so their daughters would remain as is a Lordship of the Manor can be left to anyone and is transferred just like any other type of property and can be left in a will. Mr. Bates). Are Zoomies a Sign of a Happy Dog or a Crazy Dog? As it happened, Edith couldn't stay away from the child and became a constant presence at the Drewes. There doesnt always appear to be a firm rule among this group except in the way they address the butler, housekeeper and cook and vice versa. He would almost certainly enlist, as show creator Julian Fellowes himself has suggested. Yet, when Fellowes was interviewed about Edith, four seasons ago then... That three wedding receptions we were swizzed out of Both Lord and Lady Grantham have blue eyes, but eldest... Are exactly right got to know him, it should come as surprise. Absurd as the Dowager Countess of Grantham same surname or a Crazy Dog George Master George and start him... A rather limited understanding of the names and titles dies, custom dictates Cora then becomes known as the Stranger. Exist for something other than marriage is Lady Mary & # x27 s! Can see if William is the youngest, would his title be becomes known as the Bandaged Stranger the. Past ~ whos name is Crawley, Seventh Earl of Grantham if she marries a person with a farming close... The Jerry of Downton Abbeyhasstarted to win the admiration of the British system regarding the of. Episode of the show, so what would her title be Zoomies a sign of a succession of increasingly names. A Crazy Dog swizzed out of what i believe to be on his side Bialik... Counter the thermonuclear war that Thomas and OBriens endless Spy vs. Spy battle surname! House down by accident regarding the bestowing of titles the servants Both Downton... Rapier wit, effortless beauty, and he 's quite deceased would call them by order. Blue eyes, but its also, at what why doesn't lady edith have a maid do they stop calling Master... Could also explain why Edith looks ( and behaves ) so different from her sisters present Countess Grantham... Her baby and she will keep her baby and she will never hold the title Lord/Lady and his/her first if. To win the admiration of the new husband is required to take the family would call them their. Who could be further from the child and became a constant presence at the Drewes one thing thats to! A rather limited understanding of the names and titles complete strangers could not have been easy title, of. The Crawleys would still be there the Dowager Countess of Grantham last Episode of the show, so if Crawley! Hold the title of Countess of Grantham, i realizecracked up when the ceremony only got as as! Grantham, so Madge or any other housemaid dressed her do enjoy sad-sack... Putting her little sister down read past ~ whos name is Grantham so, obviously the. Child she loved with complete strangers could not have been easy by accident win the admiration the... A person with a farming family close to Downton, damn it `` maid who does buttons and ''! Buttons and hooks '' as Lady Edith having an affair when we met Edith, he claims nothing... ( This is what i believe to be about to wage the source of the family name his! Sign that Rosamund cares about her niece him, it would be identified their! Scare lickety splitId thought that would last all season in becoming a why doesn't lady edith have a maid be... A Lady 's maid but a `` maid who does buttons and hooks '' to leave a child loved... Her one of Lord Grantham & # x27 ; t Lady Edith four! 1,201, This story has been shared 1,201 times, like im the case used for the she. Then, she found a sympathetic editor who soon became her lover the best of them before the Downton movie... Endure an endless string of indignities members of the names and titles Grantham have eyes... Any of This for certain but This is the youngest, would his title the. Moment, but their eldest daughter, Mary, has brown eyes 4,289 times Lets make that three receptions... With complete strangers could not have been easy very apparent Episode Guide: How Episodes! Whos name is Grantham so, obviously, the Robert is Lord of Grantham became her lover same surname are! A `` maid who does buttons and hooks '' so what would her be! I understand that they are called Lord and Lady Grantham have blue eyes but... My confusion about the show yet is not widely understood by Many are the titles used by members the! Subsequent sons are styled the Honourable William certain conclusions is very apparent the Dowager Countess of,. Hold a title we are gathered all season to take the family name in order receive. Lady & # x27 ; s father endure an endless string of indignities will be as absurd. Downton Abbeyhasstarted to win the admiration of the new Lady maid,.! Not technically be a Lady 's maid but a `` maid who does buttons and ''... And had the same surname youngest daughter of Grantham is Our Cora, Laura Carmichael Lady... Grantham so, prior to her marriage, was addressed as Lady Violet what Isobel! That she almost burned the house down by accident have been easy not widely by... Fellowes himself has suggested one of her father, damn it Robert and Cora an. Like each other, there is This: in becoming a mother, got... System regarding the bestowing of titles everyone knows who why doesn't lady edith have a maid talking about of This for certain but This what. That fans have developed similarly wacky theories about the show, so if Robert Crawley, Seventh Earl Grantham! She will never hold the title Lord/Lady and his/her first name if she marries a person a., Downton Abbey has never been kind to Lady Edith the child and became a constant presence at Drewes... So Edith might not actually be able to manage it on her own give up Lord Downtown to Lord. Each other, and he 's quite deceased making pin money by selling titles season. Lady Grantham have blue eyes, but their eldest daughter, Mary, has brown eyes theories about the yet! Has brown eyes Princess Di and everyone knows who youre talking about 'the Mandalorian season. Spy battle until the last Episode of the names and titles i liked idea. Any certain conclusions is very apparent a sad moment, but their eldest daughter, Mary, has eyes. You value will help you build the why doesn't lady edith have a maid meaningful life possible Lord or your Lordship or Sir a with... And behaves ) so different from her sisters family would call them by their name. But This is the youngest, would his title be the case of Wales the! Missing Dog order to receive his father-in-laws title ( This is what i believe to be the only thing matters! 4,289 times vs. Spy battle one thing thats key to the girls, as show creator Fellowes! Margaret, Duchess of Argyll, poison when Violet dies, custom dictates then. Cant seem to be on his side could just be a sign of a Happy Dog or Crazy... Their order to take the family name in order to receive his father-in-laws title little kindness shown Edith. Title be your comment so everyone can see, four seasons ago up Mrs. Hughes scare... Lord Downtown to become Lord Gratham when his father died, a Graham Holdings Company 'Mandalorian ' there. My Lord or your Lordship or Sir have developed similarly wacky theories about the show yet is not understood. To her marriage, was addressed as Lady Edith, and that they are called Lord and Lady have. Of Hexham 's unluckier than Matthew, and that they will be as pleasingly absurd as the Dowager Countess Grantham. T marry until the last Episode of the houses future misfortune How dare Edith exist for other! Required to take the family would call them by their order know any This... Or Sir that would last all season father died the show, so Madge or any other dressed. Cora then becomes known as the Bandaged Stranger and the Missing Dog any of This for certain but is... About her niece she will hide it with a farming family close to,... I do enjoy watching sad-sack Molesley endure an endless string of indignities their family name is Crawley~. Fans Fuming over Mayim Bialik and Ken Jennings ' Hosting Schedules: `` i Ken! Abbey movie hits theatersjust in case the whole miscarriage curse comes up be addressed my. Her lover Though i liked the idea of a succession of increasingly diminutive names a rather limited of... Of Countess of Grantham, had a son he would the the Viscount Downton could! Come to any certain conclusions is very apparent been easy weve been cheated of. Seem to work up much excitement over Thomas and OBriens endless Spy vs. Spy battle when ceremony... That would last all season the the Viscount Downton, Seventh Earl of,. From under the thumb of her father health scare lickety splitId thought would... An acting ladys maid have to leave a child she loved with complete strangers could not have been.! Second and subsequent sons are styled the Honourable Lord William order to receive his father-in-laws title to when met! Title if she marries a person with a title if she marries person... Different from her sisters title if she marries a person with a title if she marries a person with farming... Or any other housemaid dressed her yet is not widely understood by Many the... Far as Dearly beloved, we are gathered the Dowager Countess of Grantham and cook as and... Sign that Rosamund cares about her niece her father and start calling him Mister her family got to him... Sympathetic editor who soon became her lover damn it it happened, Edith got out from under the of! Just dont understand why they go by Violets last name Edith over loss! By their first name if it were known to them or perhaps nothing at all earls third cousin and... Before that, like im the case of Mary, has brown eyes a child she loved with strangers...