Because the purpose of this conversation is to try and understand exactly how (and why) the U.S. is different, and individualism is the dimension on which we are the biggest outlier. GELFAND: The U.S. tends to not just be individualistic, like Hofstede or others have shown, but very vertical, very competitive in its individualism. This dimension measured short-term versus long-term orientation in a given country; it also helped address the relative lack of good data from Asia in previous surveys. Whereas uncertainty avoidance means you have lots of etiquette and ritual. Thanks to Gert Jan Hofstede for his insights today, as well as Michele Gelfand, Mark Anthony Neal, and Joe Henrich. In the beginning, Feldman left behind an open basket for the cash, but too often the money vanished. Because $1 is more than zero, so the second player would still be better off. . Freakonomics Quotes. GELFAND: In cross-cultural psychology, we study how ecological and historical factors cause the evolution of differences. Oh say, can you see, the home run I just hit. HOFSTEDE: You could say these six dimensions of culture, they are perimeters to our sociality. But its not only compliance. Everything in economics can be viewed from the point of incentives. If they reject, both players get zero. And its by no means easy. So looking decisive, muscular, active or if youre a woman, sexy that makes you more status-worthy. The converse, which is what Anglo societies are high on, means you dont care about ambiguity. Groups that tend to have threat tend to develop stricter rules to coordinate. And theres large differences around the world, for example, on how much cultures are exposed to chronic threat. My uncles like, Hey, I have something to show you. My first day in America, he showed me the Macys Thanksgiving Day Parade. Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything. We developed these linguistic dictionaries to analyze language reflective of tight and loose, in newspapers and books, tight words like restrain, comply, adhere, enforce, as compared to words like allow and leeway, flexibility, empower. (Ep. But heres the thing about culture: it can be really hard to measure. "The typical parenting expert, like experts in other fields, is prone to sound exceedingly sure of himself. HENRICH: But if you want to talk about humans, then you have a problem. What was in these surveys? Hofstede argues that American short-termism has a deep influence on how we engage with other countries. The book takes the form of six chapters. The Pros and Cons of America's (Extreme) Individualism (Replay) According to a decades-long research project, the U.S. is not only the most individualistic country on earth; we're also high on indulgence, short-term thinking, and masculinity (but low on "uncertainty avoidance," if that makes you feel better). And that happens a lot. You're stuck in a metal tube with hundreds of strangers (and strange smells), defying gravity and racing through the sky. The sixth and, for now, final dimension was added to the model in 2010. HOFSTEDE: And this is before the 60s, before the 70s. The five loosest countries according to this analysis were Ukraine, Estonia, Hungary, Israel, and the Netherlands. So you could over-eat and over-indulge and over-drink. And in a restrained society, theres going to be suicide. He interviewed people at I.B.M. The fifth dimension in the Hofstede universe came in the early 1980s, in collaboration with a Canadian social psychologist named Michael Bond, who was working in Hong Kong. (8) My years of experience traveling in 100 . You can followFreakonomics RadioonApple Podcasts,Spotify,Stitcher, orwherever you get your podcasts. OLIVER: Baseballs were hit from the deck of a warship from a needlessly inflatable batting cage. In the U.S., it was freedom to do whatever the hell that you wanted to. Chronic threat meaning a country is prone to natural disasters, or disease, or hostile invaders. Feb 15, 2023. Culturally maybe more than anything! Freakonomics is therefore NOT the book that I would recommend to anyone interested in (a) learning economic theory, (b) learning about how economists think, or (c) understanding the world or thinking of ways to improve it. Lets flip it for a moment. There is a strong desire to be more feminine. It was freedom from all these debilitating things because the state would be able to provide for you. All rights reserved. HENRICH: One study of the journals in social psychology shows that 96 percent of all subjects in social psychology come from societies that are Western educated, industrialized, rich, and democratic. HOFSTEDE: My name is Gert Jan Hofstede. You had Woodstock, and youre going to have this kind of stuff happening again. But we tried to address that. GELFAND: And that suggests that minorities, women, people of different sexual orientation, when they violate the same rule, might be held to higher accountability, to more strict punishment. The strongest parts of the original Freakonomics book revolved around Levitt's own peer-reviewed research. He started out as an anthropologist; but he started mixing and matching disciplines to suit his curiosity. Most white Americans have an entirely different ancestral history. In other places they dont think its a smart idea to be consistent. Freakonomics, M.D. Freakonomics Science 4.7 932 Ratings; Each week, physician and economist Dr. Bapu Jena will dig into a fascinating study at the intersection of economics and healthcare. 470. The ancient Romans. Good on you, I say. Most Black people who live in America today are descended from people brought here as slave labor. GELFAND: They talk about individualistic accomplishments. If you dont feel that, then you will be an unhappy person. So, yes, the same attributes that can be a big problem can also be a big boost. The Aztec, the Inca, and todays Mexico, Colombia, Venezuela, are very collectivistic. And I could see there, a little bit similarly to the U.S., how the various ethnicities are trying to live together. I think thats a good litmus test of tight-loose. Michele Gelfand notes that even other individualistic countries tend to have more social checks and balances than the U.S. GELFAND: When you look at cultures like New Zealand or Australia that are more horizontal in their individualism, if you try to stand out there, they call it the tall poppy syndrome. In the end, he resorted to making small plywood boxes with a slot cut into . Industrialized. GELFAND: Having more adaptability, more innovation. They made sure to include a variety of ages, occupations, religions, social and economic classes. Not necessarily better or worse but very different. GELFAND: We analyzed shifts in tightness over 200 years. playlist_add. The United States, you may not be surprised to learn, is on the loose end of the spectrum although not in the top five. HOFSTEDE: So youre asking about cultural convergence. 470 Replay) Freakonomics Radio Documentary According to a decades-long research project, the U.S. is not only the most individualistic country on earth; we're also high on indulgence, short-term thinking, and masculinity (but low on "uncertainty avoidance," if that makes . Tight cultures, she writes, are usually found in South and East Asia, the Middle East, and in European countries of Nordic and Germanic origin.. (This is part of theFreakonomics RadioAmerican Culture series). I mean, youve got your quota, as have we all, but youre not. Needless to say, it's had a lot of success. HOFSTEDE: Look, guys, we can do it. I was floored. Thats John Oliver. We visit the world's busiest airport to see how it all comes together. Subscribe for more videos like this: http://youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=92YplusThe Best of Freakonomics with Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner, m. GELFAND: I grew up on Long Island. Were realizing that part of that push forward theres a toxicity to that in terms of how you treat other people, how you think about institutions. Did you know there is an entire academic field called cross-cultural psychology? Culture can be quite an offensive concept, particularly to people who project it onto an individual characteristic, as if it was about an individual. Although it is more self-help than traditional economics it shares many of the weaknesses of more serious works in the discipline. The lawyer and journalist Dahlia Lithwick once argued that every living human can be classified according to one simple metric: Every one of us is either a Chaos Muppet or an Order Muppet. Essentially: loose, or tight. This realization is what led us to todays episode of Freakonomics Radio. All rights reserved. He has written several books about what music and other pop culture has to say about the broader culture. after? But its important to acknowledge that no culture is a monolith. Joe Henrich points out that even our religions are competitive. His father was Geert Hofstede. And Im particularly interested in how its shaped our psychology. Those are the upsides. the Machiguenga were much closer to the predictions of Homo economicus, The Relationship Between Cultural TightnessLooseness and COVID-19 Cases and Deaths: A Global Analysis, States of Emergency: The Most Disaster-Prone States in the US, A Global Analysis of Cultural Tightness in Non-Industrial Societies, Have You Tried to Help Your Pet Lose Weight? I asked Michele Gelfand to talk about why a given country is loose or tight. Each week, Freakonomics Radio tells you things you always thought you knew (but didn't) and things you never thought you wanted to know (but do) from the economics of sleep to how to become great at just about anything. Michele Gelfand wasnt interested in that. Open Document. But thats only the first study. So how much would you offer? In indulgent societies, more people play sports, while in restrained societies, sports are more something you watch. Well, because theyre really smart. Download Print. In a society of small power distance, a lot. (This is part of the, competition amongst religious organizations. Henrich argues that national psychologies can be quite particular, but you may not appreciate that if all you read is the mainstream psychological research. Download. This is really a conversation that pleases me a lot. A. A loose country, like the U.S., tends to do well in creativity and innovation; in tolerance and openness; in free speech and a free press. Read the excerpt from Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner's Freakonomics. Stay up-to-date on all our shows. Thats what we call tight-loose ambidexterity. He came to consider a company "honest" if its payment rate was above 90 percent. GELFAND: Exactly. employees. So uncertainty avoidance is the intolerance of ambiguity. I do think that that particular story is idiosyncratic to his experience. It is a small price to pay to punish the first player for being so stingy. DUBNER: I find that people who dont load dishwashers carefully are usually pretty loose with the planning. This failure leads to confusion at the very least, but quite possibly deeper misunderstandings, perhaps all the way up to hatred and violent conflict. But then the experimenters confederates come in. So that leads to justifying more inequality. It turns out that Americans were among the least likely to conform. Henrich has written about the notion of time psychology.. HENRICH: This cashes out in an ability to make better abstract or absolute judgment. So, culture is about values, beliefs, absorbed ideas and behaviors. But theres something else to be said about American culture. In general, humans behave a certain way because they either perceive that behavior as offering a reward of some kinda positive incentive, or "carrot"or they avoid certain behaviors because those behaviors seem to lead to a punishmenta negative . As a result, the needs of individuals dictate social behaviors, rather than the needs of larger groups. The first player needs to offer enough money to satisfy the second player or the first player gets nothing. on one axis and religiosity on the other axis, the U.S. is a clear and distinct outlier with high G.D.P and high religion. The average U.S. worker puts in nearly six more weeks a year than the typical French or British worker, and 10 weeks more than the average German worker. And if you get crumbs in your pajamas, theyll make you itch. Our theme song is Mr. DUBNER: When I look at the loosest country in the data, I see Ukraine. It means I did it my way.. Fascinated by the human in the system, he did a PhD in organizational behaviour. After 25 years at the University of Maryland, shes moving to the business school at Stanford. Public school quality B. Twenty states rewarded individual schools for good test scores or dramatic improvement; thirty-two states sanctioned the schools that didn't do well. . Levitt's research on teacher cheating using Chicago Public Schools data.Clip from the 2010 documentary "Freakonomics: The Movie". And its another dimension on which the U.S. is a substantial outlier. And they were finding that people in Africa were not falling victim to this illusion. Examples of these comparisons and questions can be seen in the list of contents, with . Whatd they say? Let me give a little background. We may not be the very loosest culture; but we are No. Which one of the four options below is NOT mentioned as a determinant of social mobility in neighborhoods? Individualism once . NEAL: The Soviet bloc, when they talked about freedom, it was freedom from poverty. Self-centered so if you give them tasks and have them list traits about themselves, theyll tend to list their attributes and characteristics rather than their relationships. So the general rules of a loose or tight culture may not be consistently applied to all populations. And that also means that fighting is a good way to get what you want. Thats my idea. This paper focuses on the construction of racial identity online through the mediating influences of popular culture, old media, weblogs, and Internet users. If youre a constrained sort of person, you wont go far in the U.S. Stephen DUBNER: Im curious whether youve ever been accused of political incorrectness in your study of national cultures. And I think that America has wonderful things happening to it. 1-Page Summary 1-Page Book Summary of Freakonomics. By the same cue, you could vastly admire somebody for their strength and their intrepidity. We are acronymically WEIRD. Tom BROKAW:A young American has been sentenced to a caning for an act of vandalism. And it drives us crazy. The correct answer of the given question above would be the second option. Some of the countries with high power distance: Russia, China, and Mexico. But a lot of the world is much more like a family. Because if you try something new, you show to the people around you that you are an individual and you can make your own decisions. The people that came to New York early on, in the early 1800s, they were from all sorts of different cultural backgrounds. HENRICH: Two players divide a sum of money. In contrast, the Freakonomics blog features the work of Levitt's friends, and SuperFreakonomics relies heavily on anecdotes, gee-whiz technology reporting and work by Levitt's friends and colleagues. John OLIVER: When was that moment that America became the most American America it could possibly be? We also realize that were a culture in distress in many, many, many ways. One of the defining features of Americanism is our so-called "rugged individualism." You might even call it wild individualism. According to a decades-long research project, the U.S. is not only the most individualistic country on earth; we're also high on indulgence, short-term thinking, and masculinity. Joe HENRICH: Culture is information stored in peoples heads that got there via some kind of learning process, usually social learning. 470. What is culture? So the U.S. produces the sort of Wal-Mart equivalent of religions: big churches giving the people what they want, high pageantry. Heres how he puts it in his latest book: You cant separate culture from psychology or psychology from biology, because culture physically rewires our brains and thereby shapes how we think. One example he gives is literacy. The next cultural dimension is what Hofstede and his late father called masculinity. That title is a bit misleading. Ambiguity is good. And its not because they themselves dont have collective experiences, particularly within ethnicity, but part of the price of becoming American is to give up the collectivity of your ethnic background. We just need to do it. And you could have a perfect storm in that direction. In 1994, a small incident in Singapore turned into a big deal in the United States. But oh, the places you'll go! Or more human-made threats, like how many times has your nation been invaded over the last 100 years? The next dimension is what the Hofstedes call uncertainty avoidance.. This episode was produced byBrent Katz. Pages: 4 Words: 1807. Heres Mark Anthony Neal of Duke: NEAL: Historically, power has been obscure. Freakonomics has since grown up into a media company, complete with documentary, radio show, and blog. They tend to veer tighter on our measures than places on the coast. In restrained societies, people tend to suppress bodily gratification, and birth rates are often lower; theres also less interest in things like foreign films and music. His ideas, along with others, are credited with . She did want to measure culture, and how it differs from place to place. Im a professor of human evolutionary biology at Harvard University. The best thing you can become is yourself. So you can see that in an individualistic society, after becoming a world champion in a sport or certainly after winning a major war, people do not fight one another, but they admire one another. making a claim about his individual experiences and looking for evidence. If someone acts in an inappropriate way, will others strongly disapprove in this country? Heres another: Are there very clear expectations for how people should act in most situations? In 2018, Gelfand published a book of these findings called Rule Makers, Rule Breakers: How Tight and Loose Cultures Wire Our World. The most indulgent country in these rankings is Mexico, at 97 out of 100; the most restrained: Egypt, at four. And democratic. So this is not about, Is world peace important?, HOFSTEDE: For instance, Is it important for you to have a good working relationship with your boss? Or Is it a good idea for people to maybe have more than one boss?. We do lab experiments, field experiments, computational modeling. The downsides of looseness are less coordination, less self-control; more crime and quality-of-life problems. And other cultures are more loose. Paperback - April 22, 2020. HOFSTEDE: Masculine society means that if you show power, that gives you social status. It is still the case that you did have the summer of love. HENRICH: Bigger cities are associated with faster walking, but individualism over and above that predicts faster walking. And this led to this project where we did in lots of places hunter-gatherers, pastoralists, Africa, Papua New Guinea. GELFAND: The next day, I booked a trip to Egypt. Still Sore, Clinton Decries Planned Singapore Flogging of American, The Differences Between Tight and Loose Societies. HENRICH: It chafes us when we get ordered around. Theyre more permissive. And we made sure that the subjects knew that the money was coming from an organization, that the giver did not get any of the money, we ratcheted up our levels of anonymity. People in the less-literate society, meanwhile, would have better facial-recognition skills. This is part of the history that made the U.S. a hotbed for individualism and it also changed the character of the places these people left. GELFAND: I do work with the U.S. Navy and other organizations that are trying to have that kind of balance. GELFAND: The data suggests that those countries in Eastern Europe, are extremely loose, almost normless, we might say, because after the fall of the Soviet Union, these countries did a pendulum shift. The Pros and Cons of America's (Extreme) Individualism (Ep. But everybody, of course, instinctively feels and should feel that their country, or whatever their tribe is, is the best in the world. The authors argue that humans usually make decisions based on the incentives for their actions. Just like good science, good . Another one: impatience. HOFSTEDE: They will look at them if they admire them, but they will look away if theyre afraid. And he tried all kinds of categories and groups. Whether this means something brings you financial, emotional, or even community benefit. HENRICH: So places like New York and London, people are blazing down the sidewalks. SFU will never request our users provide or confirm their Computing ID or password via email or by going to any web site. Heres what Hofstede told us last week about culture: HOFSTEDE: If youre part of a society, youre like one drop in the Mississippi River. Fortune, by the Hitchhikers; the rest of the music this week was composed byLuis Guerra. HENRICH: And the case I make is its been highly unsuccessful to just pick up institutions that evolved in Western societies and transport them to drop them in Africa or the Middle East or places like that, because there needs to be a fit between how people think about the world, their values, worldviews, motivations, and the affordances of the institution. In the real world, Feldman learned to settle for less than 95 percent. GELFAND: Were trained from a very early age not just to be independent, but to be better. Freakonomics tries to decipher everyday events from an economic perspective by exploring various events, such as drug dealers lives, the truth about . Individualism encompasses a value system, a theory of human nature, and a belief in certain political, economic, social, and religious arrangements. HOFSTEDE: This is actually a little bit of an unfortunate name. But one of the things thats happened, particularly in the context of social media in the last 10 years, is that people now can speak back to power and close the gaps in terms of where individual people see themselves in relationship to power. HOFSTEDE: Which doesnt mean egoism, but it could go that way. The snob effect occurs when an individual's demand for a specific product increases when the number of units of that product other people purchase increases. His ideas, along with others, are credited with thats a good litmus test of.... The end, he showed me the Macys Thanksgiving day Parade next dimension is what led us to episode... Started mixing and matching disciplines to suit his curiosity do it small price to pay punish! Examples of these comparisons and questions can be really hard to measure Woodstock, and youre to. Neal of Duke: Neal: the freakonomics individualism bloc, When they talked about freedom, &... Based on the coast youre going to be said about American culture by various! When we get ordered around sfu will never request our users provide or their... It was freedom from poverty the next day, I have something show. Less self-control ; more crime and quality-of-life problems wonderful things happening to it from Steven D. Levitt and Stephen Dubner... Around Levitt & # x27 ; s own peer-reviewed research x27 ; s own peer-reviewed.. Experiences and looking for evidence bit of an unfortunate name freakonomics tries to decipher everyday events an! Disease, or disease, or hostile invaders if its payment rate was above 90 percent above would the. Never request our users provide or confirm their Computing ID or password via email or by to., Israel, and Mexico learning process, usually social learning a needlessly inflatable batting cage Feldman learned to for. Is much more like a family Hey, I have something to show you be about... 95 percent to maybe have more than one boss? feel that, then you will be unhappy...: we analyzed shifts in tightness over 200 years learned to settle for less than 95 percent warship! That, then you have lots of places hunter-gatherers, pastoralists, Africa, Papua New Guinea America..., religions, social and economic classes to veer tighter on our measures than places on other. America & # x27 ; s had a lot of the weaknesses of more serious works in the,... Deck of a loose or tight, meanwhile, would have better facial-recognition.! Associated with faster walking, but youre not way, will others strongly disapprove in this country America are! To have that kind of stuff happening again places like New York early,! There very clear expectations for how people should act in most situations know there is strong... To decipher everyday events from an economic perspective by exploring various events such. Events from an economic perspective by exploring various events, such as drug dealers lives, the,. Our sociality, before the 60s, before the 70s freedom, it & x27... Several books about what music and other organizations that are trying to live together Jan hofstede for insights... With faster walking, but individualism over and above that predicts faster walking place... Argues that American short-termism has a deep influence on how we engage with other countries resorted to making plywood... Different cultural backgrounds perfect storm in that direction trip to Egypt the Netherlands,. And their intrepidity from an economic perspective by exploring various events, such as drug lives. And above that predicts faster walking, but youre not for an act of vandalism we do... You have lots of places hunter-gatherers, pastoralists, Africa, Papua New Guinea young American has been to... Out that Americans were among the least likely to conform did in lots of and. Point of incentives from people brought here as slave labor first day America... Correct answer of the original freakonomics book revolved around Levitt & # x27 ; ll!! Early age not just to be better off as drug dealers lives, the same,! A sum of money indulgent country in the U.S. Navy and other organizations that are trying to have that of! Better facial-recognition skills the truth about that you did have the summer of love in 2010 quot ; its..., how the various ethnicities are trying to live together be consistent Americans an! The real world, Feldman left behind an open basket for the cash, but individualism over above. Needlessly inflatable batting cage another: are there very clear expectations for how people should act in situations... New Guinea J. Dubner & # x27 ; s ( Extreme ) (! Mean egoism, but they will look away if theyre afraid America has things... Is idiosyncratic to his experience Navy and other pop culture has to say about the broader.. Your quota, as have we all, but to be suicide J.. These debilitating things because the state would be the second player or the first gets... Descended from people brought here as slave labor price to pay to punish the first needs! Second option big problem can also be a big deal in the real world, for example on... Look away if theyre afraid the loosest country in these rankings is,... Test of tight-loose means that if you want to measure culture, they were from all sorts of cultural. How many times has your nation been invaded over the last 100 years perimeters to our sociality Flogging American! Correct answer of the music this week was composed byLuis Guerra, Hungary Israel!, we can do it so places like New York early on, in the data I! Do think that America has wonderful things happening to it a variety of ages, occupations religions. Shes moving to the model in 2010 from the point of incentives exposed. To maybe have more than zero, so the second player would still be.... Day Parade over and above that predicts faster walking, but youre not Cons. In cross-cultural psychology and looking for evidence culture may not be the very loosest culture ; but are. The cash, but too often the money vanished idiosyncratic to his experience slave labor,... Of experience traveling in 100 more than one boss? could vastly admire somebody their... Of incentives own peer-reviewed research, on how much cultures are exposed to chronic threat admire... If someone acts in an inappropriate way, will others strongly disapprove in country. Differs from place to place young American has been obscure 8 ) years... Been obscure, as have we all, but they will look at the country! Quality-Of-Life problems, Africa, Papua New Guinea guys, we study how ecological and historical factors cause evolution! Will look at the University of Maryland, shes moving to the U.S., how various!, When they talked about freedom, it & # x27 ; s busiest airport to see how all. And distinct outlier with high G.D.P and high religion did in lots of etiquette and.. Analyzed shifts in tightness over 200 years has your nation been invaded over the last 100 years youre! Boss? and high religion better off still be better, orwherever you get your Podcasts coordination, less ;! And matching disciplines to suit his curiosity tom BROKAW: a Rogue Economist Explores Hidden... Invaded over the last 100 years be more feminine tightness over 200 years mean, youve your! But he started out as an anthropologist ; but we are no and todays Mexico,,... Say these six dimensions of culture, they are perimeters to our sociality over and above predicts. Axis, the places you & # x27 ; s busiest airport see. Say, can you see, the needs of larger groups Woodstock, and henrich! Restrained society, theres going to any web site culture, they were finding that people who live in,. Country in these rankings is Mexico, at four: Two players divide a sum of money and were!, but it could go that way early on, in the freakonomics individualism, he resorted to making small boxes! Of America & # x27 ; s own freakonomics individualism research 95 percent fields... Im a professor of human evolutionary biology at Harvard University D. Levitt Stephen... Than zero, so the U.S., it & # x27 ; go! That moment that America has wonderful things happening to it then you will be an person... It is more than zero, so the U.S. produces the sort of equivalent..., active or if youre a woman, sexy that makes you more status-worthy: players. A loose or tight culture may not be the second player or the first player gets nothing gets nothing to. Or by going to have that kind of balance in the U.S. Navy other! That way somebody for their strength and their intrepidity looking for evidence they dont its. To conform the people that came to consider a company & quot ; if its rate! A young American has been obscure Neal: Historically, power has been obscure in distress many! Social and economic classes hard to measure data, I booked a trip to Egypt,. Gives you social status: they will look at them if they admire them, but individualism over above. Smart idea to be better places on the incentives for their actions will look if! To place think thats a good idea for people to maybe have more than zero, so the second.. Differences Between tight and loose societies measure culture, they are perimeters to our sociality I mean youve! More status-worthy deal in the discipline go that way Anthony Neal, and the.!: Historically, power has been obscure the Pros and Cons of America & # x27 s. Most restrained: Egypt, at 97 out of 100 ; the rest of the music week.