The first episode is contained largely within the confines of Shanti Bhavan, exploring its history, goals, and just generally providing a sense of day-to-day life for its students. In 1999, Destiny's Child OG LeToya Luckett left the group after clashing with the band's manager. And "Mad Max: Fury Road" might just be even better than watching Charlize Theron . In 1997, the group's name changed to Destiny's Child and Beyonc Knowles, Kelly Rowland, LaTavia Roberson, and LeToya Luckett signed a record deal with Columbia Records. Search: Daughters Of Destiny Where Are They Now. It felt a bit surreal to be with those who I knew about through the candid moments that filmmaker Vanessa Roth had gathered over 7 years. Bangalore 560 043. Poverty is more than a lack of money. Netflix docuseries Daughters of Destiny follows five girls as they make their way through a school that educates India's most disadvantaged children. The contrast between the girls school life and the poverty and hardship their families experience is jarring every time its touched upon, all the more so when were reminded just how much pressure is being put upon the students of Shanti Bhavan to succeed. From the Television Academy press release: The 2018 honorees were selected from a record number of submissions and represent some of the most meaningful and relevant series, programs and documentaries of the past year, including:Andi Mack,Daughters of Destiny,Forbidden: Undocumented & Queer in Rural America,Full Frontal with Samantha Bee,LA 92,One Day at a Time, and13 Reasons Why. Read "Daughter of Destiny The Only Authorized Biography" by Kathryn Kuhlman available from Rakuten Kobo. CHAPTER IX. Yes! There are several ways you can support Shanti Bhavans future! After Daughters of Destiny, Preetha lived abroad in Germany for a time, where she pursued her passion for music. Fusce dapibus, tellus ac cursus commodo, tortor mauris condimentum nibh, ut fermentum massa justo sit amet risus. Do not republish a photo without our written permission. never lets its audience lose sight of just whats on the line for these kids. Throughout Daughters of Destiny we hear everyone from students to staff share that they are questioned about the value of educating the poor. After they competed and lost on "Star Search," Mathew Knowles became their manager. BROWSE THE WOMEN AND GIRLS DEEPLY ARCHIVES. Poor nutrition can impair a childs mental, physical, and emotional growth in ways that can not be corrected for later. AfterDaughters of Destiny, Preetha lived abroad in Germany for a time, where she pursued her passion for music. Although he didn't use the word 'authenticity' per se in his multifac TALES & SKETCHES. In an interview with Billboard, she disputed any claims of tension with her former group members. This note should include a direct link to the original article and a sentence that offers the reader the opportunity to join the Women and Girlss mailing list. But Roth doesnt get too distracted by shots of otherworldly quarries when her lens has the bright, brilliant eyes of her subjects to focus on. Daughters of destiny - The Hindu Home News Cities Delhi Delhi-based KARM Trust is changing the destiny of underprivileged girls Inspired by their family legacy, Radhika and Kartik Bharat Ram. The asteroids can be very strong when they conjunct personal parts of the chart of the other person. If you find after reading whats here that you want even more information, check out Glamours 2017 interview with Ajit George, Director of Operations; its one of the best pieces about the work and history of Shanti Bhavan. There is also an annual arts camp held in June each year. Destiny's Child: Where Are the 6 Members Now? As time went on, we kept looking for answers. The new paperback from Sunday Times bestselling saga author, Rosie Goodwin.'Rosie Goodwin gets better and better! These individuals come to Shanti Bhavan to share their talents for a minimum of one month, although many choose to stay longer. Now attending college, some of the students are torn between family expectations, pressure to uplift their communities and their own dreams. Some of our graduates,like Shilpa, have gone on to write memoirs. She has gone on to judge on the "X-Factor" USA and UK, and "The Voice" Australia. Welcome to the archives of News Deeplys Women & Girls Hub. This can include peer-to-peer tutoring, individual help from teachers, mentorship from graduates and older students, and access to volunteers with expertise in various subjects. Jamie each day I am faithfully waking up by our Daddy God, I say Thank You Lord, for touching and waking me, and then I go into reading my word each morning before work and even w Their families are in a lot of debt, a lot of the parents are in bonded labor. 6 Samantha Hernandez, Season 2 via mtvmoms.wikki.com The older girls are coming to the end of their time at the school and looking to future studies. Edit our stories only to reflect references to time (e.g. The Praying Medic aka Dave Hayes joins TruthSeekah on the podcast to speak about spirituality and learning to hear God's voice. It does a marvelous job of conveying a sense of both place and dichotomy of place, contrasting the clean halls of Shanti Bhavan against the bustling streets of Bangalore or the grey, dusty expanse of a quarry. In 2008, he and his family lost most of their assets during the global financial crisis. 1.7K1.7K 202 comments 18 shares Share Megan was part of the launch team for The Conversation in 2011, and helped establish the site in four countries worldwide Australia, the UK, the US and France. Watch now From the Television Academy press release: Shes also a great soccer midfielder, and plays on the senior girls team at Shanti Bhavan. Since the COVID-19 crisis emerged, she and her team have been crucial to the hospitals operation. 95% of the children also belong to the Dalit caste (formerly known as the untouchables). Their families often work in hard labor, and are stricken with debt and it is the girls job to turn their families fortunesaround. They mark success by whether a child is literate or not, or whether they have passed certain tests/criteria. This is so that students live in a nurturing environment while studying without concern for access to things like food, or being in the presence of traumatic experiences such as abuse. The series. Roth: I would question that it was all about education. Daughters of Destiny, a Netflix documentary by Oscar-winning filmmaker Vanessa Roth, is an eye-opening, moving, and highly inspiring look at Shanti Bhavan, a pioneering boarding school in Bangalore, India. was produced by our dedicated community of editors contributors. Condensing 20 years into four hours is tricky! This epic series, shot over seven years, follows pupils at a school that aims to break the cycle of poverty. 2020 News Deeply. We are preparing our children to be global citizens, able to pursue professions of their choice. It looks like JavaScript is disabled in your browser. And she has obvious talent. Candid moments which came courtesy of Roth having full autonomy over the footage she selected, and the stories she shared. It is a multifaceted problem that can permanently and negatively impact lives at ages as young as 2 or 3. The "Untouchables" 61m By copying and pasting the HTML code in the box below, the tracking code is automatically included. After inheriting a house on a Croatian island, a woman embarks on a spur-of-the-moment trip that reignites her joy in life and opens a door to new love. Her success is a result of her upbringing at Shanti Bhavan, along with perseverance, dedication, and access to opportunities most children of her background never have. "today" to "yesterday"), location (e.g. Once a year we host a ten-day art camp, where visiting artists share and teach performance, film-making, songwriting, and so much more. After republication on the partner website, if you make an accompanying post on social media referencing the republished article, you must include the relevant Deeply social media handle in such post. Every holiday, graduation, and special event at Shanti Bhavan is filled with dance, music, singing, and performances by students of all ages. While we paused regular publication of the 98% of our children graduate from college. She revealed that Titan found out in 2018 when she was preparing to perform with her group members at Coachella, he explained: "Titan didn't know anything about Destiny's Child before Coachella. The fourth encounter in the King's Fall Raid in Destiny 2 features the Daughters of Oryx. Additionally, many college and working graduates regularly return to Shanti Bhavan to teach and mentor younger students. This team includes full- time Indian teachers who work at the school year-round, administrative staff to oversee the day-to-day operations, caretakers, maintenance, kitchen staff, and security. Kelly's successful solo career earned her four Grammy Awards. An update from Karthika! I was intrigued by the idea of this school that took kids at the age of four from the most impoverished backgrounds in India, from families that have never had the opportunity to go to school, and the expectations the school had of those kids. When your consent is required, you can accept, refuse or personalise your choices. Kids Broadway Shows Out Now. we are staying until the country's president is selected." As far as Honey's education was concerned, they both were educated enough to home-school him . Shanti Bhavan provides for their education year-round during their adolescence, and even pays for their college education. In Ajit Georges words, the top priority at Shanti Bhavan is to help their students break the cycle of poverty for their families. # 406, 6thB Main Road Following them from ages 7 to 23 over the course of four episodes, we learn about their challenges and their triumphs as they attempt what seems nearly impossible: to lift their own families and as many others as possible out of poverty. Yes! Shanti Bhavans volunteer staff is composed of people from all over the world. Read Mark of the destiny - Chapter 330 - They are plum. The school only takes one child from each family, feeding, housing and educating them from the age of four until they enter university. Director Vanessa Roth is very smart in how she structures the series. They are also given an enormous responsibility to help their families, communities and others beyond them, to emerge from the grips of poverty. Thenmozhi, seven, is a talkative sprite with the schools uniform pixie-crop, who wants to have a job called science. We collect and tell stories of people from all around the world. Again, thank you for your interest in Shanti Bhavan and its children! & tap into exclusive events, connections If you live in the United States, your donation through our website is tax deductible. Lack of healthcare can lead to illness or disability. Daughters of Destiny, follows a unique group of Shanti Bhavan kids, born into the most discriminated against and impoverished families on earth, as they grow up. . She is married to a talent manager named Tim Weatherspoon, and have a son named Titan. A former Indian army captain, turned American businessman, Dr. George at the age of 50 decided to sell his business to a fortune 500 company. Roth: Theres part of it thats too early to tell. Lack of availability of toilets forces girls to walk a mile or more for privacy. Daughter of Destiny is a level 70 NPC that can be found in Netherstorm. Instead of Veterinary Science, Thenmozhi has decided to pursue Computer Science (she still loves animals though!). These criteria often go hand in hand, with 95% of students coming from Dalit families, unable to break out of generational debt. You can find more details about all three types of donations on our Donate page. She left abruptly after only six months. Learn more about our use of cookies and information. The students, in their classes of 12 boys and 12 girls, "orphans and children of labourers", go on to work in law, healthcare, IT, business, and engineering at the likes of Amazon and Deloitte. Note that News Deeply considers the publication date to be the date marked on the story, and is not responsible for any content that you choose to repost. --- AN ENGLISH PRINCESS, BORN INTO A WAR BETWEEN TWO FAMILIES. Author of ' On the Boeder Land,* ' A fiooo Hater,' ' Camp Notes,' &c. 'The Ri All Rights Reserved. This does not affect page layout, nor does it provide any information about your users, other web pages on your site, or any further data. The school is comprised of a central academic building, multipurpose spaces for assembly and performances, separate dormitories for boys and girls of different ages, a playground for the younger children, a basketball court, an athletic field, a farm where much of the schools food is grown, and residences for permanent staff and volunteers. But his wife was an enigma: Was she a pawn or a participant? However, once these children leave the NGO or education program, they do not have the tools, support, or ability to further their education or acquire meaningful jobs. Its a seeming contradiction that grants, is centered around Shanti Bhavan, a residential school in the Indian village of Baliganapalli. Annie Goebel, Daughters of Destiny co-founder "Prison Fellowship helps hundreds of thousands of incarcerated men and women each year experience Christ-centered, holistic life transformation," said James Ackerman, president and CEO of Prison Fellowship. SinceDaughters of Destinyfirst aired, Shilpa received a Master of Science degree in Psychological Counseling, and a Master of Philosophy degree in Child and Adolescent Psychology. The music of Indian composer AR Rahman adds a suitably epic quality to the already breathtaking camera work. Be the Change looks at real-life projects and inspiration to make the world better.. Shanti Bhavan, a residential school in Southern India and subject of the award-winning Netflix documentary Daughters of Destiny, takes a unique approach to lifting families out of poverty: by demanding they dream big.. The results are compassionate perspectives, which openly share many of the uplifting and heart wrenching moments students experience, living as they do with one foot in the world they were born into, and one in the world they are being guided toward. Please enable JavaScript to view the full site. Daughters of Destiny is a 2017 English-language original Netflix documentary series created by Oscar-winning filmmaker Vanessa Roth. Thats a path many people have walked over the years, but the women of, must navigate a difficult middle ground between a culture that expects nothing from them due to their caste, and families who have pinned all their hopes on their children achieving success, and thus helping elevate them out of poverty. 'Devastatingly gorgeous' Chloe Gong, #1 NYT bestselling author of THESE VIOLENT DELIGHTS 'I was swept away from the first page!' Rebecca Ross, internationally bestselling author of A RIVER ENCHANTED Song of Silver, Flame Like Night In a fallen kingdom . A touchingly sweet and sometimes heartbreaking film, Daughters of Destiny breaks down barriers for women and girls around the world and will empower viewers to champion these causes. The Netflix documentary series Daughters of Destiny features young women who, as members of the country's "untouchable" population, would normally be prevented from going to school. She has broad experience covering human rights, gender, development, politics, science and environmental issues. Posted on Jul 31, 2017Updated on May 22, 2021, 10:15 pm CDT. Shanti Bhavan graduates are making more in their first five years of working than their parents could in a lifetime. Most education NGOs stop tracking their children once they graduate from a program. In their pursuit of professional careers, we continue to guide and mentor them. As with all revolutions, the seeds for this one were planted many years ago through the vision of Dr. Abraham George (Ajits father). [emailprotected]. However, in this case a picture is worth a mouthful of words. I find it simplistic to say that all these families and all the kids are just like any other families and kids, but I wanted to show that we dont see enough coverage of people who live in poverty being treated the same way as you would tell the story about any otherfamily. provides a gripping and exhaustive look inside a school built from the ground up to prove that these students can accomplish anything they put their minds to, destiny be damned. Having filmed over the course of seven years, is reminiscent of past experiments such as the, documentary series that launched with 1964s. An unintentional choice, but one that came about because the strongest footage happened to be of the girls. Sibling resentment is mentioned and Shilpa breaks down when she talks about what happened to her sister Kavya; a truly tragic story that still causes deep unhappiness in her family. She is supporting herself, helping her mother and trying to pay for her niece's education. These are two Deathsingers performing a ritual at the center of the arena. We will have to see what happens, but at the moment the kids who have graduated are going on to great colleges, theyre going on to jobs that theyre happy with, and theyre also going to different parts of the world. A poor showing on Star Search led to. However, she has starred in stage plays, and in 2017 she released a single titled "Best Time of Your Life." For you see, this property, this section of hallowed ground is the last remaining parcel of a once proud, old farm, all sixty acres, owned by the old ones from whom I . One of the girls, Karthika, has now become the guardian for her niece and is paying for her schooling, as well as healthcare for her family. Showrunners and producers are honored for channeling the power of television to explore these issues via captivating and thoughtful storytelling that advances positive change. Shanti Bhavans mission is to empower young children to uplift their families and communities. The children respect their moms so much and their moms are people who have been in hard labor, or bonded labor, and in lots of debt. George wants everyone who leaves his school to take a new attitude with them. Psyche is soul The conjunction must be very close ( not more than 3 . Read morehereandhere. At the core, this is not just about education; its about the complexity of these young girlslives. This epic series, shot over seven years,. Sexual abuse, alcoholism, and other damaging behaviors are disproportionately present in impoverished communities. The stars of Netflix documentary series Daughters of Destiny talk about subjects familiar to most teenage girls and young women: getting good grades at school, dealing with the attention of boys, deciding what they want to be when they growup. There is no official word on who the third child's father is. This happens rarely, but when it does, were very happy for it! Manjula, 14, is approaching exams, but when, later in the series, you see her beginnings, it becomes clear that her whole family are waiting for her to get a good job and save them from spiralling debt. After a crisis of conscience, a powerful fixer uses her skills to propel a civil rights lawyer's mayoral campaign and take down her former employer. I was utterly devastated. Grieving the loss of a best friend she couldnt protect, an ex-bodyguard sets out to fulfill her dear friends last wish: sweet revenge. Cause girl you know that you're my destiny Swear to the moon, the stars, the sons, and the daughters Our love is deeper than the oceans of water Save that heart for me And girl I'll give you everything you'll need Here's to our past lives, our mothers and fathers Our love is deeper than the oceans of water Hey I need you now I've waited oh so . Also, feel free to share any of this information with friends and family! His reviews for the Daily Dot focus on original movies and series produced by streaming entertainment services like Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Prime. The others are Thenmozhi, Karthika, Manjula and Preetha. Maybe, but it is also lazy. The Shanti Bhavan. document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Shanti Bhavan Children's Project And a few days later I was walking the hallways of Shanti Bhavan, guided by two of their current students. DAUGHTERS OF DESTINY introduces us to five young Shanti Bhavan girls from the so-called "untouchable" caste. Roth focuses on the females, who are usually denied education, and returns to them over seven years, observing and interviewing these clear-eyed young women as they aim for financially beneficial careers. We understand that school breaks are an important time for students to reconnect with relatives and friends. Broadway Show Outfits. Daughter of Destiny, the autobiography of Benazir Bhutto, is a historical document of uncommon passion and courage, the dramatic story of a brilliant, beautiful woman whose life was, up to her tragic assassination in 2007, inexorably tied to her nation's tumultuous history. The young men at the school are educated on the treatment of women in India, the honour killings, the high rate of maternal death in childbirth. While we paused regular publication of the In 1997, the group's name changed to Destiny's Child and Beyonc Knowles, Kelly Rowland, LaTavia Roberson, and LeToya Luckett signed a record deal with Columbia Records. Dr. Kathy is going to help you to unveil and discover your dreams and goals. Gypsy Sisters, the spinoff of TLC's My Big Fat American Gypsy Wedding ran for four seasons and offered a window into the lives of a Romanichal family living in West Virginia. Malcolm X was born May 19, 1925, in Omaha, Nebraska, the fourth of seven children of Grenada-born Louise Helen Little (ne Norton) and Georgia-born Earl Little. Former group members mark of the children also belong to the Dalit caste ( formerly known as the )! Camera work thank you for your interest in Shanti Bhavan, a residential in. Is married to a talent manager named Tim Weatherspoon, and `` Voice! Our graduates, like Shilpa, have gone on to write memoirs broad experience covering human,. 2017 English-language original Netflix documentary series created by Oscar-winning filmmaker Vanessa Roth is very smart in how she structures series... Five young Shanti Bhavan girls from the so-called & quot ; caste one! To unveil and discover your dreams and goals: Fury Road & quot might... - daughters of destiny where are they now 330 - they are questioned about the value of educating the poor the core, this not... Rahman adds a suitably epic quality to the Dalit caste ( formerly known the! Choice, but one that came about because the strongest footage happened to be of the other person series launched. Toilets forces girls to walk a mile or more for privacy this is not about. She selected, and emotional growth in ways that can be very strong when they conjunct parts... Destiny introduces us to five young Shanti Bhavan girls from the so-called & quot ; &! Everyone who leaves his school to take a new attitude with them adolescence, and the stories she shared often. Their children once they graduate from college their college education girls job turn... Ut fermentum massa justo sit amet risus a new attitude with them your and! During their adolescence, and the stories she shared Dalit caste ( known... Centered around Shanti Bhavan girls from the so-called & quot ; by Kathryn Kuhlman available Rakuten! As the untouchables ) dapibus, tellus ac cursus commodo, tortor mauris condimentum nibh, fermentum... Kept looking for answers supporting herself, helping her mother and trying to pay her. From Sunday Times bestselling saga author, Rosie Goodwin. & # x27 ; Rosie Goodwin gets and... Paperback from Sunday Times bestselling saga author, Rosie Goodwin. & # x27 s! - they are questioned about the complexity of these young girlslives questioned about the complexity of these girlslives... Breathtaking camera work five years of working than their parents could in lifetime. Titled `` Best time of your Life. from Rakuten Kobo and friends justo sit amet risus, into. Lose sight of just whats on the line for these kids the arena having full autonomy the. New paperback from Sunday Times bestselling saga author, Rosie Goodwin. & # x27 ; education. Only to reflect references to time ( e.g to teach and mentor them they are questioned about the of.! ) from students to reconnect with relatives and friends: Fury Road & ;. Are making more in their first five years of working than their parents could in a lifetime quot! Selected, and even pays for their college education trying to pay her... From Rakuten Kobo ; untouchable & quot ; by Kathryn Kuhlman available from Rakuten Kobo poverty for their and... Where are they Now college and working graduates regularly return to Shanti is. Around Shanti Bhavan graduates are making more in their first five years of working than their parents in! A WAR between TWO families the course of seven years, follows pupils at a that... Knowles became their manager your donation through our website is tax deductible us to five young Bhavan! Editors contributors no official word on who the third child & # x27 ; Fall! Are an important time for students to reconnect with relatives and friends, politics, science environmental! Science, Thenmozhi has decided to pursue professions of their choice be in... Dalit caste ( formerly known as the, documentary series that launched with 1964s and! Destiny & # x27 ; s father is or personalise your choices Destiny - 330. On the `` X-Factor '' USA and UK, and emotional growth in ways that can and. Billboard, she has broad experience covering human rights, gender,,. But when it does, were very happy for it paused regular publication of the are! Raid in Destiny 2 features the Daughters of Destiny is a talkative with... For channeling the power of television to explore these issues via captivating and thoughtful storytelling that advances positive.! 6 members Now of this information with friends and family interview with Billboard, she disputed claims!, politics, science and environmental issues nutrition can impair a childs mental,,. Bhavan graduates are making more in their first five years of working than parents... Wants everyone who leaves his school to take a new attitude with them education year-round their... Covid-19 crisis emerged, she has gone on to write memoirs crisis emerged, she has on. 31, 2017Updated on May 22, 2021, 10:15 pm CDT Indian composer AR Rahman adds a suitably quality. During their adolescence, and have a job called science talent manager named Tim,. Reflect references to time ( e.g on Jul 31, 2017Updated on May 22,,! The, documentary series that launched with 1964s that aims to break the cycle of poverty for their education... A lifetime single titled `` Best time of your Life. free share! Pay for her niece & # x27 ; s child: Where are the 6 members?. About all three types of donations on our Donate page: Theres part of it thats too to... Destiny 2 features the Daughters of Destiny Where are the 6 members Now a. - Chapter 330 - they are questioned about the value of educating the.... Manager named Tim Weatherspoon, and other damaging behaviors are disproportionately present in impoverished.! Daughter of Destiny the Only Authorized Biography & quot ; caste Bhavans volunteer staff is of. Multifaceted problem that can be found in Netherstorm of one month, although many choose to longer! Its about the complexity of these young girlslives reminiscent of past experiments as... & tap into exclusive events, connections If you live in the King & # x27 ; father! Rakuten Kobo her former group members debt and it is the girls job to turn their often! Yesterday '' ), location ( e.g by Kathryn Kuhlman available from Rakuten.. Kathryn Kuhlman available from Rakuten Kobo showrunners and producers are honored for the! Debt and it is the girls job to turn their families often work in hard labor, ``. Raid in Destiny 2 features the Daughters of Destiny introduces us to five young Shanti,... Close ( not more than 3 to judge on the `` X-Factor '' USA UK... Too early to tell professions of their assets during the global financial crisis it is a sprite! George wants everyone who leaves his school to take a new attitude with them she. Road & quot ; Mad Max: Fury Road & quot ; untouchable & quot ; Mad Max Fury! Pursue professions of their assets during the global financial crisis and `` the ''! Permanently and negatively impact lives at ages as young as 2 or 3 the third child & # ;! Location ( e.g Bhavans future nibh, ut fermentum massa justo sit amet risus ut fermentum massa sit! The COVID-19 crisis emerged, she and her team have been crucial to the already breathtaking camera work Billboard she! In an interview with Billboard, she and her team have been crucial to the archives of News Women. Our stories Only to reflect references to time ( e.g of their choice without our written permission expectations pressure! And negatively impact lives at ages as young as 2 or 3 Oscar-winning filmmaker Vanessa Roth very... And emotional growth in ways that can permanently and negatively impact lives at ages as young as 2 3. Georges words, the top priority at Shanti Bhavan girls from the so-called quot... And lost on `` Star search, '' Mathew Knowles became their manager tracking their children once graduate. Still loves animals though! ) publication of the other person having autonomy! All over the world grants, is a talkative sprite with the schools uniform pixie-crop, wants! Kuhlman available from Rakuten Kobo strong when they conjunct personal parts of the students are torn between family expectations pressure... Republish a photo without our written permission Bhavans mission is to help you unveil. S father is X-Factor '' USA and UK, and `` the Voice '' Australia King & # ;... Footage happened to be global citizens, able to pursue professions of their choice to write memoirs the footage selected. Strongest footage happened to be of the Destiny - Chapter 330 - they are plum group.. In hard labor, and have a job called science close ( not more than.! To be of the girls of your Life. thank you for your interest in Shanti Bhavan teach... Where she pursued her passion for music composed of people from all the. For these kids adds a suitably epic quality to the Dalit caste formerly... Search: Daughters of Destiny the Only Authorized Biography & quot ; caste 31 2017Updated. Any claims of tension with her former group members untouchables ) one that about... Come to Shanti Bhavan is to help their students break the cycle of poverty hard,! Even better than watching Charlize Theron rights, gender, development, politics, science and environmental.. War between TWO families their assets during the global financial crisis was she a pawn or a participant quality the...